NYLJ: Proposed Settlement Surfaces in Dispute Over City's 18-B Plan


Five county bar associations and New York City may soon settle their differences over a city plan to shift the bulk of an estimated 44,000 cases a year now handled by private, court-assigned counsel to institutional providers such as the Legal Aid Society.

Under a draft stipulation now being circulated, the bar organizations would abandon their state lawsuit challenging the plan. In exchange, the city would assure the bar groups that they would retain oversight responsibilities under a new indigent criminal defense plan to be negotiated by the two sides...

The five bar groups have filed a separate lawsuit challenging the city plan to shift cases on constitutional grounds. The city has removed that case, NYGLA v. Bloomberg, 10-cv-5035, to the Southern District federal court, but the draft proposal makes no mention of it, Neither David Siegal, a lawyer at Haynes and Boone who represents the bar groups, nor Mr. Pines would comment.

This article has been excerpted from The New York Law Journal. To read the full article visit their website. (Subscription required.)

Email Disclaimer